Public Notice is proudly celebrating 5 years of independent journalism. Support our work by becoming a paid subscriber ⬇️
The Democrats’ 2026 state-level victories have fueled the party’s hopes for enacting the National Popular Vote Plan to change the way America elects its presidents.
The NPVP is an interstate compact designed to guarantee that the presidential candidate who wins the national popular vote automatically receives a majority of electoral votes needed to become president. If a sufficient number of states approve it, the NPVP would eliminate the possibility of so-called “misfired” or “wrong winner” results like the 2000 and 2016 elections, defeats that chafed and devastated millions of liberals and Democrats.
Several notable, newly-elected Democrats are advocating for the NPVP to prevent another misfire — to make sure Republican presidential nominees, who benefit from greater support in the small red states that cast more electors-per-capita, do not win despite amassing fewer popular votes nationwide.
“We can do away with [the Electoral College]," declared Wisconsin's Democratic governor-elect David Crowley who, coupled with his party’s control of both state legislative chambers, will reign over the Democrats’ first “trifecta” in the state since 2011. "I am interested in having those conversations with the state legislature."
An aristocratic vestige
How would the NPVP work, what are its prospects for adoption, and what sort of political and legal hurdles might it face? Answering these questions first requires a closer look at the Electoral College, the vestigial and aristocratic election mechanism the Founders created but would hardly recognize today.
Because the 55 white male elites who assembled in Philadelphia in 1787 to draft the new Constitution feared popular inputs, they envisioned a system in which presidents were selected, not elected. State elites would appoint electors every four years to meet in December in their respective state capitals to assess the candidates and then cast their votes for president and vice president. Together, these state-level deliberative bodies comprise the Electoral College.
By the early 19th century, and without amending the Constitution, states changed their laws to begin choosing electors based on popular votes, not elite selection. Eventually all states did, and today all but two — Maine and Nebraska excepted —assign their electors winner-take-all to whichever presidential candidates receives the most votes statewide.
Because each state’s electoral vote counts equals its US House members plus two US senators, the Electoral College gives smaller states more relative power. California is 68 times the size of Wyoming, but the ratio of California’s 54 electors to Wyoming’s (guaranteed minimum) three electors reduces to 18:1. Bush and Trump won because the Electoral College inflates the power of smaller states, which on average are whiter, more rural, and thus more Republican.
The other major critique of the Electoral College is that the winner-take-all assignment of electors compels presidential campaigns to ignore voters in all but the most competitive states, and also creates millions of so-called “wasted votes” in the non-swing states for both presidential candidates. In 2000, for example, Al Gore could take neither the surplus votes from his comfortable victory in California nor some of his worthless losing votes in Texas and redistribute them to Florida where he needed them — and vice versa for Bush in those two states and for both candidates in the other 40 states where the statewide winner was never in doubt.
How the NPVP works
Computer science professor John Koza invented the National Popular Vote Plan to ensure that the national popular vote winner becomes president without needing to amend the Constitution to eliminate the Electoral College.
Animated by the principal of states’ rights, Article II explicitly grants states the authority to appoint electors “in such Manner as the Legislature thereof may direct.” The NPVP forms an interstate compact wherein each member state uses that authority to cast their electoral votes for the national popular vote winner, regardless of how candidates fared in their respective state.
The compact includes a triggering clause so that the NPVP only takes effect if the number of combined electors cast by state signatories reaches or exceeds 270; barring that, the compact remains dormant and each state continues to assign its electoral votes winner-take-all to its statewide popular vote winner.
The 18 states plus the District of Columbia that have already ratified the compact currently cast 222 electoral votes, 48 shy of the majority. Given the Democrats’ greater enthusiasm for eliminating the Electoral College, it is no surprise that the 19 compact members so far are among the nation’s bluest states. Conversely, the red states’ refusal to adopt the NPVP has prevented the compact — so far — from attaining the magical 270 electors.
A variety of scenarios, however, could push the NPVP above the 270-elector triggering threshold.
Both chambers of Nevada’s legislature and one chamber each in five other states — Arizona, Arkansas, Michigan, Oklahoma, and South Carolina — have already passed the NPVP. Were the remaining chambers and governors of those six states and their combined 61 electoral votes to ratify, the compact would activate. However, Arkansas, Oklahoma, and South Carolina all elected or reelected Republican governors in 2026.
Midterms change the calculus
The 2026 midterms provided new momentum for adopting the National Popular Vote Plan.
Democrats forged six new state “trifectas” where, starting in January, the party will control the governorship and both legislative chambers. Those six states cast 65 combined electors and include three states mentioned above where the NPVP has partially advanced: Arizona, Michigan, and Nevada.
Three other states — New Hampshire, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin — have more hurdles to clear. In addition to Wisconsin’s Crowley, Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro, who cruised to reelection this month, is open to supporting the NPVP in his state, which casts 19 crucial electoral votes, though he gave it a lukewarm endorsement.
“I’ll work with lawmakers to figure out what the right mechanism is for moving forward on that. But look, we’re the ultimate swing state in Pennsylvania,” Shapiro said a few days after the election. “I think Pennsylvania can still play a massive role even in a national popular vote.”
A number of key Democrats who soon will either take office or rise to chamber leadership positions — including Nevada’s governor-elect Aaron Ford and incoming state Senate majority leaders in Arizona and Michigan — have also indicated their support for the National Popular Vote Plan. Ford, who is African American, cited two factors in defense of his position: The recent misfires of 2000 and 2016, and the racist structure of the Electoral College.
He is correct about the latter critique, and for two reasons. First, as mentioned above, the Electoral College presently assigns greater voting weight to smaller, whiter states. The second reason is that the institution was motivated in part by the “original sin” compromise the Founders made in Philadelphia to appease the slave-holding southern states. Although the Founders could not peer 250 years ahead to envision the relative population sizes and racial composition of today’s 50 states, the Electoral College still animates their racist impulses.
“I didn’t initially support [NPVP] frankly because I hadn’t done enough research on it, but I have researched it and, looking at the Electoral College, understanding the, frankly, racist underpinnings of it in the first place leads me to believe that we need to get rid of it,” Ford told a Nevada TV station. “Not only for that reason, but because we’ve seen several times now the person who wins the popular vote not win because of the Electoral College.”
Expected resistance
Should some combination of states with the additional electors needed to reach 270 adopt the National Popular Vote Plan, or come close, expect Republican officials and the conservative media to aggressively oppose it.
Spearheaded by Save Our States — an organization funded by the conservative Bradley Foundation and Leonard Leo’s Concord Fund — NVPV opponents will almost certainly launch a massive, coordinated counterattack. Expect a group of red state officials to file one or more federal cases challenging the NPVP on constitutional grounds, specifically whether it violates interstate compact law.
Without delving too deeply into legal thickets, several law review articles or other scholarly publications have addressed potential constitutional objections to the NPVP. Those challenges will almost certainly turn on the interpretation of the Supreme Court’s 1893 Virginia v. Tennessee ruling on interstate compacts, specifically whether states can exercise their Article II powers to decide the “manner” by which they award electors by compact.
Political scientist Nicholas Miller has further addressed two logistical complications the NPVP could create. First, there is no formal method nor official government agency to certify the winner of the national popular vote in the way state election officials certify statewide popular vote winners. Second, although states have used their Article II authority to designate the popular vote results as the determinant for assigning electors, the Constitution does not require them to do so. If some states chose to appoint their electors by the state legislature or other means, as was done during the colonial era, there may no longer be a national, 50-state popular vote winner for the NPVP to certify as deserving the electoral vote majority.
Liberals and Democrats may also want to take a beat before jumping on the NPVP bandwagon, cautions Talking Points Memo founder Josh Marshall. The tabulation of a national popular vote could lead to a dangerous federalization of national elections. States’ autonomy to decide their electoral rules, Marshall reminds, provided a powerful safeguard against the Trump administration’s attempts to manipulate election rules and ballot access from Washington.
Popular voting for president is popular
According to Pew, 63 percent of Americans support abandoning the Electoral College in favor of electing presidents by national popular vote. The most effective way to achieve this change would be to ratify a constitutional amendment that alters Article II’s language. But the chances that two-thirds of both the US House and Senate will propose such an amendment are at best slim, and the prospects of three-quarters of states ratifying it are none. The Electoral College is here to stay.
Although the National Popular Vote Plan operates within Article II’s electoral parameters, that will hardly save it from rulings by state and federal judges. If Democrats in the necessary states ratify the compact, a titanic legal fight will commence immediately. With its nakedly partisan Bush v. Gore ruling, the Supreme Court settled the 2000 election when the Court’s five conservative justices shed their supposed veneration of states’ rights to rule that the equal protection rights of voters in Florida were subordinate to those of candidate George W. Bush. Does anyone doubt the Court’s current, six-justice conservative majority will defer to states on the constitutionality of NPVP?
In the next two years, expect some of the new blue trifecta states to adopt the National Popular Vote Plan. Others may take longer or punt until after the 2028 presidential election. Expect a nasty political fight in the federal courts to ensue.
None of which will matter if Democrats produce a blue wave in the 2028 presidential election even half the size of the midterm tsunami they delivered in this year’s midterms. Such a wave will yield a presidential candidate who not only wins the popular vote but captures a comfortable Electoral College majority — with or without the NPVP in effect.
That’s it for today
We’ll be back with more tomorrow. If you appreciate today’s PN, please do your part to keep us free by signing up for a paid subscription.
Thanks for reading.







I'm no fan of the current electoral college system, but my biggest concern about going entirely with the popular vote is logistical. After watching the Bush vs Gore and Al Franken vs Norm Coleman recounts, I think a national recount in a very close election would be a nightmare. I wonder if states' electoral votes could be allocated on a proportional basis (with rounding) so that if candidate A won 60% in a state and candidate B won 40%, 60% of that state's electoral votes would go to candidate A and 40% to candidate B. That would still make individual states count, and it would reduce recounts only to states where the vote is close.
Alarming. Democrats are just stupid enough to try to pull this off. They will win one election, then lose the next ten before the country crumbles under authoritarian rule from rigged, federalized elections.