Public Notice is proudly celebrating 5 years of independent journalism. Support our work by becoming a paid subscriber ⬇️
Young voters — especially young men — swung dramatically to Democratic candidates in this year’s election, more than almost any other demographic group.
According to a Tufts University analysis of AP Votecast data, men under 30 voted for Donald Trump over Kamala Harris by a 14-point margin in 2024 (56-42 percent), but this year, they voted for Democrats by a 59-37 percent margin, a 36-point swing. It was a shift of stunning magnitude.
But hold on — wasn’t it just two years ago that Trump supposedly forged a powerful cultural bond with those same young men? Didn’t he model an unapologetic masculinity that offered them an island of acceptance in a world of stifling wokeness, winning their loyalty to him and his movement? How could that support have evaporated so quickly?
The answer is that Trump’s connection to young men was always a mirage.
Some men were certainly attracted to the kind of belligerent, overcompensating masculinity that Trump represents, which fully became part of the Republican Party brand in 2024. But they were always a minority of young men, and whatever appeal he had for them would never be enough to overcome a record of failure in office.
Correlation, not causation
It’s easy to see why so many believed that in 2024 Trump had won over millions of young men as men.
His campaign planned and executed a strategy to win over young men through a particular kind of cultural affinity. He went on one dudebro podcast after another and got endorsed by the King of the Dudebros, Joe Rogan. He showed up at UFC fights with his good friend Dana White. He advertised heavily on sporting events. He entered the RNC convention to the strains of James Brown’s “It’s a Man’s Man’s Man’s World.”
In other words, the story went, he met the young men where they are — lonely, disenchanted, and looking for purpose.
Trump’s message to young men in 2024 had two parts. First, he told them that they are indeed oppressed: The world mistreats them, scorns them, scolds them and abuses them, while undeserving chicks get all the jobs and all the respect. Second, he told them that the solution is to reassert their power in the most belligerent way possible. Be rude, be crude, spend 12 hours a day listening to those podcasts, refine your peptide stack, download more gambling apps, vote Republican, and redemption will be yours.
When Trump performed significantly better among young men in that election, the causality seemed obvious: Since his campaign was unusual in those highly visible ways, that must have been why the results turned out the way they did. As the Washington Post wrote just after the election, “Trump’s staggering showing among this demographic was the culmination of a years-long effort to reach young men devoted to the beacons of American machismo: pranks, combat sports, stand-up comedy and the often-misogynistic online fringe known as the ‘manosphere.’”
Then when he took office, the macho-signaling only intensified. He hired a bunch of lunkheaded fake tough guys like Pete Hegseth, RFK Jr., Sean Duffy, and Markwayne Mullin for high-ranking positions in his administration; they may not have had much in the way of qualifications, but they loved posting cringy workout videos. He held a UFC event on the White House lawn, the lowlight of which was the troglodytic fighter Josh Hokit grabbing the mic after his win to shout “Michelle Obama is a man!”
Hegseth announced that service members would be screened for testosterone levels, to ensure that warfighters would be properly hormone-maxxed. White House social media teams delivered an endless stream of fascist-inflected internet memes celebrating violence.
But none of it did anything to improve the material conditions of young men’s lives, and even the podcast bros who had been so enthusiastic about him quickly started to notice. One after another — Theo Von, Adin Ross, Andrew Schultz, Joe Rogan — they started criticizing him, especially for the brutality of his immigration crackdown.
One vital but largely unnoticed driver of that shift was the simple fact that in 2024, Trump was the edgy outsider, while a year later he was the president. It’s cool to be on the side of those who appear to be fighting The Man; it’s a lot less cool to be a cheerleader for The Man.
The seeds of Trump’s fall with young men were there all along
As a group, the young men who supported Trump in 2024 looked different from both older Trump voters and the young men who supported Trump four years before: They were less likely to call themselves conservative and more supportive of renewable energy, immigration, and government action to solve problems more generally.
In other words, the young men who voted for Trump in 2024 were more liberal than other Trump voters.
So what motivated them? Displeasure over the economy, far and away the issue most cited as the reason for their votes. Trump picked up a lot of support from young men anxious about their prospects and unhappy with the status quo. But in 2020, Trump was the status quo, just as he was in this year’s midterms when those voters swung back to Democrats. The young men who moved his way two years ago weren’t doing so because he found a key that would unlock their affection forever more; they just wanted something different. They still do.
In other words, most young men are driven by the same impulses that other voters are, especially dissatisfaction with the economy and the desire for change. If they’ve swung back and forth more dramatically than some other groups in the last few elections, it could be largely because their partisan attachments are less firm.
It could also be that over the last two years, they’ve wised up to the fact that for all their preening, today’s MAGA chuds are the most unappealing bunch of whiners on the planet.
They may have tired of Trump’s constant complaints that everyone is being mean to him. They might have seen how Trump surrounds himself with a collection of pathetic sycophants with zero self-respect, men who will wear the wrong size shoes if Trump tells them to. Maybe they got tired of being told they should be filled with rage about Hollywood casting decisions and boycott yet another product for being too woke, or of the way being an obnoxious douchebag alienates you from friends and family.
Perhaps they don’t actually want to join a movement full of groypers and neo-Nazis. They don’t see paunchy ICE goons cosplaying like they’re about to invade Fallujah kidnapping housekeepers and landscapers, and say “Yeah, that’s cool!” They may realize that Republicans who say they’re terrified of extremely safe American cities are wimps.
Maybe — just maybe — a lot of young men figured out that the masculinity on offer from MAGA is the most pathetically anxious, insecure version imaginable, and no real man would want to have anything to do with it.
To repeat, there are certainly some young men for whom the MAGA version of manhood is appealing. But saying “this is what young men want” is like saying “young women want to be tradwives.” Some young women certainly want to be tradwives, but most don’t.
Most important, when a political movement fails to deliver on the material promises it makes — and Trump made plenty of material promises — the masculinity playacting looks even more hollow. The economic paradise Trump said he would create is farther away than ever; instead we got tariffs and more inflation, another Middle East war, spiraling costs for housing and healthcare, a world drowning in AI slop, the spread of the scam economy, air traffic shutdowns, the most corrupt administration in history, and a general feeling of precarity and loneliness that only seems to get worse.
In the face of all that, what did Republicans offer to the voters this year? A campaign full of attacks on Democratic candidates for being supposedly effeminate or too indulgent of trans people. It failed spectacularly.
Today, Andrew Tate and Russell Brand sit in jail, the Cybertruck is being discontinued, and young men helped deliver the most dramatic midterm sweep for Democrats since Watergate. Maybe the kids are not just alright, they’re better than we gave them credit for.
That’s it for today
We’ll be back with more tomorrow. If you appreciate today’s PN, please do your part to keep us free by signing up for a paid subscription.
Thanks for reading.






It’s too bad those young men hadn’t paid attention to the failures of Drumpf’s first term and his attempted coup on 1/6/21.