17 Comments

In the era of $250,000 RV gifts and hob-nobbing with ecclesiastical influencers, it’s heartening to know that only sex carries a whiff of impropriety sufficient to disrupt the workings of our “system” of “justice.” S/

Expand full comment

The judge overstepped. He should have limited testimony to whether there was a financial benefit, or not. That’s the only corrupting influence: the accusation was that it might cause Fani to drag out the case. Fani isn’t dragging out the case; the defendant is.

We can scream all we want about how Fani Willis can’t make a single misstep, because it’s somehow “on her” to save the country from this mess. That’s unrealistic and particularly annoying when the expectation is directed at a Black woman.

We are ALL entitled to the pursuit of happiness and that if two adults who work with one another want to have a sexual relationship—regardless of anyone’s marital status—that’s their choice. Whether she and Wade have sex is irrelevant.

Expand full comment

I agree that Wade and Willis should have known better but it’s quite hypocritical and ironic that trump is claiming that HER speech at the church was improper and inappropriate. I’ve lost track of how many gag orders he’s had, he still has, and how many he’s violated.

Expand full comment

All this because a rookie judge did not have the cojones to deny an irrelevant motion.

Expand full comment

Thank you!

Anything for delay; but Willis and Wade should have avoided this self-inflicted wound.

Expand full comment

Quick reminder that there is a goddamn tape recording of Trump pressuring state officials to rig the election in overturn a free, unfair result. This entire sidebar was misdirection.

Expand full comment

Is it that lay people can't understand how court is supposed to work, or that this actually was how a hearing conceived and run by Judge McAfee worked? The prosecutors became the defendants and the defense the prosecution, but none of the normal rules and processes applied. The defense (Roman party) brought little evidence - there didn't appear to be any rules of evidence - and their evidence didn't show what they claimed, so they switched claims. Their witnesses were unwilling and easily impeached (and "sexual impropriety" as used in this reporting is a euphemism of the extent of the Bradley impeachment.) The attorneys for the defense were a series of bumbling fools ("self-inflicted quagmire"???), trying to pile on to Merchant's weak base, and they lost. The first 9 of the 23 pages of the McAfee ruling documents their loss, and the rest goes back and forth between the lack of professionalism and poor arguments on both sides; the defense ones continue being brought, as part of the pile-on, to court.

The question of how this ruling is appealed - Wade resigned, so the prosecution doesn't appear to be preparing for an appeal - and in what other venues the defense can maintain the upper hand to further subvert the legal system - well, that's what this lay person will be watching.

Expand full comment

I love how when we are talking about a black woman, the “appearance of mendacity” is enough for a judge to rush to judgement. But have a convicted rapist and liar and we all have bend over backwards to let him do whatever he wants. That judge is a racist, cowardly, piece of shit and I hope he steps on legos barefoot every day for the rest of his life.

Expand full comment

While laughing with glee at hearing Fani Willis trying to back foot the defense with her fiery statement about “not being on trial,” I’m not surprised that the judge took umbrage. She was basically yelling at the defense counsel, and scolding her.

Agree or disagree that the judge should/should not have scheduled this hearing, he did. As often as we say that “anyone else would already be in jail,” we also have to apply that “anyone else “ standard to the conduct of people we like.

In this case, “anyone else” would also have been held accountable by the judge. And he did caution her from the bench. It just hurts to see it in writing.

Expand full comment