16 Comments
User's avatar
Douglas Mackay's avatar

Are arrogance and ignorance prerequisites to be considered for elected office in the Republican Party? Either party? Given the number of medical professionals who get involved with politics and then become embroiled in scandal, one could assume either the medical profession needs to strengthen its moral and ethical standards or political organizations need to do better vetting candidates. Wait. How naive. Of course.

Michael Wild's avatar

The person on the excelent YouTube channel "Let's Talk Elections' states that for states like Kansas and Texas to be lost needs a combination of a very unfavourable national environment, a strong Democrat candidate and a weak Republican one. Marshall didn't see that all these boxes are being ticked. Anyone in touch with farmers (pretty important in Kansas) would know that if tariffs are brought in and trade wars started farmers are the first casualties because there's plenty of other places you can get agricultural imports as happened very rapidly with the big Chinese export market. But the former doctor clearly didn't know this,

A rational political party would look to put its best retail politicians in the swing states (and give these people a big say in political strategy) and look to put less flashy policy wonks that would make good cabinet members or leaders in the safe states. That is definitely not how things are working in the Republican party (I don't know the internal the Democrats). It seems that the most extreme and electorally unsuccessful policies come from 'safe' Republican districts and states. I'm pretty sure that explains why the Republicans embraced banning abortion which is an electoral stinkbomb....however beloved in the grass roots of Republican +20% branches.

David J. Sharp's avatar

Odd assumption — that any Red State politician cares anything about serving the people … instead of their own pocketbook.

Chuck's avatar

I assure you that MANY farmers are happier with our economy being destroyed if it means Republicans keep power for life so that all the "illegals" aren't "stealing all the benefits" that they cannot get because they are undocumented (Schrödinger's "Illegals": simultaneously taking all the jobs AND taking all the unemployment and Medicare they cannot receive. Very complicated math and logic required) 😄

Depending upon the Farm Bill (if ever passed...), farmers with insurance are relatively safe from the shocks that we have; so the fact that PedoPINO has wrecked the soybean trade, and his stupidity and lack of understanding of... EVERYTHING... have also hurt wheat farmers where I live, affects them less than if there was no insurance and they were stuck "holding the bag" with thousands of bushels of wheat in the elevator but nowhere to sell it and having to pay storage fees after Halloween every month until sold (or selling at a whatever loss the current market pays...a terrible prospect that leaves you "farming until you go broke."

I am basing this on what most of the farmers I deal with are talking about with other people (because of my clearly anti-Republican, pro-Constitution, pro-lawfulness, anti-corruption militancy, I don't talk politics at work: EVERYONE knows where I stand...and some secretly agree despite the overwhelming red-ness of this area and my Independent views on actually honoring the Constitution that makes us American...)

Maryjane Osa's avatar

Wonderful morning read. My hope: this column is just a palate cleanser and its theme will be reprised many times over the coming months.

Mike Truman's avatar

Even if Hamilton loses, I hope he maintains a presence. We need more Christians explaining what the Gospels actually say, not what the Republican party pretends is there.

T L Mills's avatar

And you know who else seems to feel that she is owed her 6th Senate term? Our Lady of the Furrowed Brow, Maine's ever-concerned, pearl-clutching Senator, Susan Collins. Susie has recently begun bragging about how she--all by her lonesome, no doubt--has gotten Trump to eliminate the tariff on road salt. WOOOOOooo.

Well, granted that will certainly help with the winter road maintenance budgets for Maine towns. However, it's not the big deal Collins is making it out to be. As Troy Jackson points out, no one eats road salt.

Town budgets are relatively immaterial to the everyday financial predicament that Trumps OTHER tariffs have handed to the average working family. Collins has also gotten her old buddy, Bill Greene*, a supposed "independent", to do another series of campaign ads for her. Although...it may not have the magic effect that his ad had in her last campaign. Actually it may blow up in both their faces. Goodness, I sure as heck hope so!!

(*Bill Greene is a local television personality who does a program called "Bill Greene's Maine" where he visit various iconic sites or events in Maine and does friendly, somewhat informative interviews with the owners or the locals and it more or less highlights places to visit or events to go to for everybody, including tourists.)

Susie does seem to be getting a little panicky however...her ads have taken a real nasty turn, stopping at the edge of defamatory. I am keeping my fingers crossed that this time we can pry her butt out of that cushy Senate chair (and toes, eyes and anything else I can cross).

Koko in AZ's avatar

The entire Republican party is unconsciously incompetent.

Susanna J. Sturgis's avatar

Add Tommy Tuberville to the list. Here in blue Massachusetts, the Republican Party didn't go full MAGA till fairly recently -- we had a sane Republican governor in Charlie Baker from 2015 to 2023 -- so the incompetence of these red-state Republicans is startling. Moral of story: One-party situations aren't good for democracy.

Since it's looking like many states are heading into a one-party situation, with that party being the Democrats, should I be worried that it might happen to us? I think not -- because there's enough diversity within the Democratic Party, at both the state and national level, that we're not likely to get too complacent.

Ann Beyer's avatar

I had heard a sketchy story about this. Nice to have more details. Thanks.

Ed Walker's avatar

Berlatsky points out that farmers aren't able to pass along their increased costs to purchasers. There's a reason for that.

Farmers sell almost all of their produce to a tiny group of purchasers, like Cargill, a privately owned company. This is called an oligopsony. The purchasers don't even have to organize. They just set their prices publicly and magically the other purchasers match.

Farmers can't organize to protect themselves. They are at the mercy of the filthy rich owners of the purchasers. This has been a problem for farmers since the late 1800s. The novelist Frank Norris wrote The Pit and The Octopus around 1900, describing the damage this market structure did.

Now the problem is compunnded by private equity, vulture funds that buy up farms in foreclosure or sold in distress sales. That's J.D. Vance.

Suel J's avatar

How disgusting. This asshole had women at their most vulnerable. He literally had them on their backs in stirrups. And sent cops when they couldn't pay a bill?? Fuck completely off. Women: avoid male OB GYN practitioners. Don't come on and extoll the virtue of yours. This is my advice.

Susan Travis's avatar

Noah, I could apply these informative points directly, DIRECTLY! to the GOP candidates in my state,Tennessee! Marsha Blackburn running for governor refuses to debate Jerri Green. She will go on Fox News to espouse her maga talking points, but didn't even debate the other republican candidates for governor!! She feels entitled to be senator and to be Tennessee governor 🙄 Many thanks for this excellent piece!💙👊

SCOTT BRIZARD's avatar

Brilliant piece once again! Love the roach references!

David J. Sharp's avatar

Donald Trump—very ironically, the anti-Midas.

kdsherpa's avatar

"Don’t they recognize that he is their rightful ruler, entitled to 18 percent interest, a Senate seat, and the obeisance of the press?" BINGO!!!!!